View Thread
|
Rewatch Downunder Saturday 20th January A3 CYGNUS ALPHA
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:22
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And there you have it. Avon says it exactly how it is. They will never have the same chance again. And they will get dragged into Blake's crusade. It's all Jenna's fault. Like far too many people, willing to give away their integrity for a pocketful of mumbles such are promises (as those prophets Simon and Garfunkel put it). Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:23
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
The interesting thing about all the prisoners moaning and groaning is the power of suggestion. Like people on a ship: they see someone with sea-sickness and they all get it.
Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:24
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. |
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:24
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
I do like Vargas' robes.
Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:25
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| M1795537OCVirn |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:26
|
|
Admin ![]() Posts: 15902 Joined: 14.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. But it works for Vargas and friends. I wonder if V was the first to set up the sickness thing or if he inherited the secret from someone else? "You're not sulking, I hope?"
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:26
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? |
|
|
|
| Tyce |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:27
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 3202 Joined: 16.01.22 |
Fabulous rewatch, fabulous company, but now I really have to go to bed. Good night everyone. |
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:28
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. But it works for Vargas and friends. I wonder if V was the first to set up the sickness thing or if he inherited the secret from someone else? My feeling is that it was a good lark that had been tried before but that he grew into the role of applying it as a matter-of-course. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| M1795537OCVirn |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:28
|
|
Admin ![]() Posts: 15902 Joined: 14.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. "You're not sulking, I hope?"
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:28
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Indeed! To their ideologies. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:28
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. But it works for Vargas and friends. I wonder if V was the first to set up the sickness thing or if he inherited the secret from someone else? I think the sickness is probably genuine - it might be related to the three-day sweats mentioned in Killer. But it is just a natural reaction to space travel/something in the planet's environment, and it passes quickly. |
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:29
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Indeed! To their ideologies. What ideologies? I see only a desperation to remain in power here at the moment. |
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:29
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. Goes with the territory. Humans demonstrate again and again that they are herd animals. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:30
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Indeed! To their ideologies. What ideologies? I see only a desperation to remain in power here at the moment. By busily smashing to bits people in other countries, and, should I add: that's all part of convincing you that they are keeping at bay all those wicked people who might challenge your (our) culture. Our pathetic lot are doing it too. Sacrificing others to prove to a domestic market how terrific they are. Edited by Obsidian on 20-01-2024 10:35 Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:32
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. Well, I suppose that Vargas and his ancestors were from Earth, and were people of limited culture and imagination, so went with all the cliches - the robes, the chanting, the torture, the sacrifices. And it makes for a lively backdrop for the real meat of the episode, which is Blake's attempts to build a crew. But I would still have liked something more interesting. |
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:34
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. Well, I suppose that Vargas and his ancestors were from Earth, and were people of limited culture and imagination, so went with all the cliches - the robes, the chanting, the torture, the sacrifices. And it makes for a lively backdrop for the real meat of the episode, which is Blake's attempts to build a crew. But I would still have liked something more interesting. Well, as I've noted before, they (Vargas et al.) are curiously cross-cultural in their selection of devices – artefacts – with which they reinforce their claims. They just dragged in all the usual stuff – chanting, sacrifices etc. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:36
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Indeed! To their ideologies. What ideologies? I see only a desperation to remain in power here at the moment. But busily smashing to bits people in other countries, and, should I add: that's all part of convincing you that they are keeping at bay all those wicked people who might challenge your (our) culture. Our pathetic lot are doing it too. Sacrificing others to prove to a domestic market how terrific they are. But they are not trying to convince us - we are a lost cause to them. They have found a sizeable minority who can be convinced that their culture is under threat. The rest of us don't need to be convinced, in fact must not be convinced, because we are needed as the internal enemy who are the willing dupes of the external enemy and must be destroyed. |
|
|
|
| M1795537OCVirn |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:38
|
|
Admin ![]() Posts: 15902 Joined: 14.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. Well, I suppose that Vargas and his ancestors were from Earth, and were people of limited culture and imagination, so went with all the cliches - the robes, the chanting, the torture, the sacrifices. And it makes for a lively backdrop for the real meat of the episode, which is Blake's attempts to build a crew. But I would still have liked something more interesting. Yes, it's all built on stereotypes. But TN was still working on the characterisation: he's trying to make everything fit together ideas, future, budget, and in particular the actors they've cast. One of the strengths of B7 is the way they responded to the strengths of the cast - just a pity that some of them didn't know they could have spoken up a bit more. Plus it was almost half a century ago. We're looking at it with different eyes (I hope) and our sterreotypes are a bit bigger/more rounded/ more cynical. "You're not sulking, I hope?"
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:40
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
Anyway, that's all getting a bit political, and a bit gloomy - I came here to be cheered up, after all. This will never rank as one of my favourite episodes, but it gets us our crew, and we move on. Thanks for the rewatch, everyone. |
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:42
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Indeed! To their ideologies. What ideologies? I see only a desperation to remain in power here at the moment. But busily smashing to bits people in other countries, and, should I add: that's all part of convincing you that they are keeping at bay all those wicked people who might challenge your (our) culture. Our pathetic lot are doing it too. Sacrificing others to prove to a domestic market how terrific they are. But they are not trying to convince us - we are a lost cause to them. They have found a sizeable minority who can be convinced that their culture is under threat. The rest of us don't need to be convinced, in fact must not be convinced, because we are needed as the internal enemy who are the willing dupes of the external enemy and must be destroyed. The usual reductive approach. But almost all 'The West' now has adopted USA-style bozo politics. Where protecting the inner keep involves going and taking things out on someone else. It keeps the internal ructions off the front page. The fact that WE – you and I – might not be convinced doesn't mean that a whole lot of others aren't. Over there you've definitely had some corkers in government lately. We're mediocre copy-cats, sadly. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| M1795537OCVirn |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:45
|
|
Admin ![]() Posts: 15902 Joined: 14.01.22 |
Well said, AnneA. Time to move on - to the hoovering etc. Vastly more exciting (NOT). Hope your mother continues to improve, Tyce. Have you done your tax thing yet Obsidian? Is that what's causing the migraines? Hope this week goes to plan for you, AnneA. Take care, all of you. Don't know where I'd be without my Saturday 'fix' of Aussie humour. "You're not sulking, I hope?"
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:47
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. Well, I suppose that Vargas and his ancestors were from Earth, and were people of limited culture and imagination, so went with all the cliches - the robes, the chanting, the torture, the sacrifices. And it makes for a lively backdrop for the real meat of the episode, which is Blake's attempts to build a crew. But I would still have liked something more interesting. Yes, it's all built on stereotypes. But TN was still working on the characterisation: he's trying to make everything fit together ideas, future, budget, and in particular the actors they've cast. One of the strengths of B7 is the way they responded to the strengths of the cast - just a pity that some of them didn't know they could have spoken up a bit more. Plus it was almost half a century ago. We're looking at it with different eyes (I hope) and our sterreotypes are a bit bigger/more rounded/ more cynical. It didn't feel wrong then because TN was a dyed-in-the-wool labour man at that stage and he could feel the nasty way the politics in the UK were going. The characters and the different points of view they represent were very believable and I still find them so. As an archaeologist I fully accept that the past is another country. The trouble is, so few people now do. They keep imposing their own worldviews. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:47
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
Anyway, that's all getting a bit political, and a bit gloomy - I came here to be cheered up, after all. This will never rank as one of my favourite episodes, but it gets us our crew, and we move on. Thanks for the rewatch, everyone. B7 IS political. That is the whole point. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| Obsidian |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:50
|
|
Moderator ![]() Posts: 8885 Joined: 15.01.22 |
Well said, AnneA. Time to move on - to the hoovering etc. Vastly more exciting (NOT). Hope your mother continues to improve, Tyce. Have you done your tax thing yet Obsidian? Is that what's causing the migraines? Hope this week goes to plan for you, AnneA. Take care, all of you. Don't know where I'd be without my Saturday 'fix' of Aussie humour. Take care MsVirn. Have fun with the vacuuming. That's me tomorrow. Tyce, sleep well and I hope you mother improves soon. AnneA, Best wishes with all you have to deal with at present. Don't philosophise at me you electronic moron.
|
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 10:58
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Indeed! To their ideologies. What ideologies? I see only a desperation to remain in power here at the moment. But busily smashing to bits people in other countries, and, should I add: that's all part of convincing you that they are keeping at bay all those wicked people who might challenge your (our) culture. Our pathetic lot are doing it too. Sacrificing others to prove to a domestic market how terrific they are. But they are not trying to convince us - we are a lost cause to them. They have found a sizeable minority who can be convinced that their culture is under threat. The rest of us don't need to be convinced, in fact must not be convinced, because we are needed as the internal enemy who are the willing dupes of the external enemy and must be destroyed. The usual reductive approach. But almost all 'The West' now has adopted USA-style bozo politics. Where protecting the inner keep involves going and taking things out on someone else. It keeps the internal ructions off the front page. The fact that WE – you and I – might not be convinced doesn't mean that a whole lot of others aren't. Over there you've definitely had some corkers in government lately. We're mediocre copy-cats, sadly. I think I disagree with you there. A depressing, and to my mind fairly recent, feature of British society is the way that quite trivial internal disagreements are bigged up and foregrounded - the enemy are all within now, and division is routinely fostered. Look at the way unisex toilets have been promoted as a huge threat to 'our' way of life! Any idea of 'One Nation', however bogus, and however much it might only have been rhetoric, has gone now. There is a corresponding lack of interest in what is happening abroad - much less coverage of foreign affairs on the news or in newspapers. In part this is because foreign correspondents are expensive, while reporting on the latest twitter spat is cheap, but it is also encouraged by the government I think. |
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 11:01
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
And human sacrifice. Cliche upon cliche. I actually don't think it's too far from how a lot of people behave. It doesn't take much. Our governments do it all the time on little to no pretext. Ritual human sacrifice? Maybe it's the robes. Once they're wearing them, people suddenly start singing Gregorian chants, offering scrifices etc. Well, I suppose that Vargas and his ancestors were from Earth, and were people of limited culture and imagination, so went with all the cliches - the robes, the chanting, the torture, the sacrifices. And it makes for a lively backdrop for the real meat of the episode, which is Blake's attempts to build a crew. But I would still have liked something more interesting. Yes, it's all built on stereotypes. But TN was still working on the characterisation: he's trying to make everything fit together ideas, future, budget, and in particular the actors they've cast. One of the strengths of B7 is the way they responded to the strengths of the cast - just a pity that some of them didn't know they could have spoken up a bit more. Plus it was almost half a century ago. We're looking at it with different eyes (I hope) and our sterreotypes are a bit bigger/more rounded/ more cynical. It didn't feel wrong then because TN was a dyed-in-the-wool labour man at that stage and he could feel the nasty way the politics in the UK were going. The characters and the different points of view they represent were very believable and I still find them so. As an archaeologist I fully accept that the past is another country. The trouble is, so few people now do. They keep imposing their own worldviews. I think that one feature of the seventies is that religion was seen as being on the way out, so could be reduced to personality cults and cliches. It hasn't faded away as people might then have hoped, so perhaps has more recently got the more thoughtful and nuanced treatment formerly reserved for politics. |
|
|
|
| AnneArthur |
Posted on 20-01-2024 11:04
|
|
Alpha Grade ![]() Posts: 8716 Joined: 16.01.22 |
Anyway, I too have hoovering to do, so had better get on and do it. I hope your mother gets well soon, Tyce. Have a good week, everyone. |
|
|
|
| Jump to Forum |





